Penny Wise, Coverage Foolish: The Risk of Insurance Bargain Hunting

When it comes to buying insurance, focusing only on price can be a costly mistake. While it’s tempting to chase the lowest premium, doing so often means sacrificing critical coverage, service, and long-term value. From confusing policy comparisons and hidden gaps to the risk of credit dings and missed loyalty perks, bargain hunting for insurance can backfire. This article explores why choosing the “cheapest” option may not actually be the smartest—or safest—decision.

  1. Focusing Only on Price Can Lead to Inadequate Coverage
    When you shop insurance purely by the cheapest price, you might end up with policies that don’t cover all your risks properly. The lowest premium may mean limited benefits, high deductibles, or coverage gaps that can cost you more in the long run.
  2. Comparison Can Be Difficult Due to Different Policy Terms
    Insurance policies can vary widely in what they cover, exclusions, limits, and conditions. Comparing prices without understanding these differences is like comparing apples to oranges.
  3. Frequent Shopping Can Hurt Your Credit Score or Record
    Some insurers do “soft” or “hard” credit inquiries during quotes. Too many requests in a short period might negatively impact your credit score or how insurers view your risk.
  4. Short-Term Savings Might Lead to Long-Term Costs
    Cheaper policies might have poor customer service or claim handling. When you need to file a claim, poor service can cause delays, disputes, or claim denials, costing more time and money.
  5. Overemphasis on Price Ignores Discounts and Loyalty Benefits
    Some insurers reward loyal customers with discounts and perks over time. Constantly switching to save a few dollars may mean losing these benefits.
  6. Insurance Agents and Brokers Add Value Beyond Price
    Trusted agents can help you understand coverage nuances, recommend the best options for your situation, and assist during claims. Shopping solely by price may cause you to miss out on this personalized guidance.

Request Your Proposal Here

Are you ready to save time, aggravation, and money? The team at Mappus Insurance Agency Inc. is here and ready to make the process as painless as possible. We look forward to meeting you!

Call Email Claims Payments